Financial Emigration vs Tax Emigration: What's the Difference?

"Financial emigration" and "tax emigration" get used interchangeably by SA expats, but they are not the same thing. Getting them mixed up can cause real problems, so it is worth understanding the difference before you take any steps.

Financial emigration (the old SARB process - discontinued)

Financial emigration was a process administered by the South African Reserve Bank (SARB) that let South Africans formally change their exchange control status from "resident" to "non-resident." It was shut down on 1 March 2021 when the SARB scrapped the distinction between residents and non-residents for exchange control purposes.

If you completed financial emigration before that date, your SARB non-resident status still stands. However, this does not automatically mean you have ceased your SA tax residency with SARS. The two were always separate processes administered by separate institutions.

Tax emigration (the current SARS process)

Tax emigration - more accurately called cessation of SA tax residency - is what matters today. It is the formal process of telling SARS that you are no longer a South African tax resident. The steps involved are: establishing your date of cessation, submitting a final tax return with a deemed disposal calculation under Section 9H, paying any Capital Gains Tax that arises, and obtaining clearance for any remaining capital movements offshore.

Once SARS confirms your cessation, you are no longer taxed on worldwide income - only on SA-sourced income. It also starts the three-year clock for accessing your retirement annuity.

Key differences

What if you completed financial emigration before 2021?

If you went through the old SARB process before March 2021, check whether you also completed the SARS side. Many expats assumed the SARB process covered everything, but it did not - SARS and SARB were always independent. If SARS still considers you a SA tax resident, you may still have worldwide income obligations and unfiled returns to deal with.

A worked example: an expat who did financial emigration in 2018 and is only now discovering the gap

A typical scenario: a 47-year-old expat in Hertfordshire, originally from Durban. He completed the old SARB financial emigration process in 2018 with the help of his SA accountant, who told him "that's everything sorted." For seven years he lived in the UK assuming his SA tax position was closed.

In 2026 he decides to encash his R1.8 million SA retirement annuity, expecting the three-year rule to apply since he formally emigrated in 2018. WBForex runs the diagnostic on his SARS profile.

What the audit shows. SARS still considers him a SA tax resident. His SARB exchange-control status changed in 2018 but his SARS tax residency was never formally ceased. The three-year clock for RA access has not started. Worse, he has seven years of unfiled SA tax returns sitting on the SARS profile, accumulating R250-per-month administrative penalties on each return.

The corrective sequence. WBForex's tax practitioners file the outstanding returns, applying the Section 10(1)(o)(ii) expat exemption to neutralise the SA tax liability on his UK employment income. Administrative penalties (approximately R21,000 across the seven years) are paid. Cessation of tax residency is then formally submitted - with the deemed disposal calculation under Section 9H, dated to a defensible point in 2018 when he genuinely became a UK tax resident.

The result. SARS confirms cessation, backdated where supportable, but the three-year clock runs from the confirmed cessation date - typically 2026 in practice unless backdating can be supported. His RA access opens in 2029, not 2021 as he originally believed.

The lesson: if you completed financial emigration before March 2021, do not assume the tax side is closed. Check it explicitly. The two processes were always independent.

The mistakes SA expats make

A few patterns:

• Assuming "I emigrated in 2017" means "I am tax-emigrated." It does not. The pre-2021 financial emigration process was a SARB exchange-control change, not a SARS tax change. Confirm both sides explicitly.
• Filing SA tax returns marked "non-resident" when SARS still considers you resident. This creates a contradiction between your filings and your registered status. SARS queries follow. The right answer is to formally cease, then file as non-resident from that point.
• Letting unfiled returns stack up under the assumption that "I left SA years ago, so they cannot affect me." They can. R250 per month per outstanding return adds up. And unfiled returns block AIT, cessation, and any future capital movement.
• Trying to backdate cessation to many years ago to recover lost time. SARS will accept a backdated cessation date if it is supported by evidence of genuine non-residency from that date (UK lease, UK employment contract, severance of SA ties). It will not accept a date chosen for convenience.
• Confusing "tax emigration" with "renouncing citizenship." Cessation of SA tax residency has nothing to do with citizenship. You remain a South African citizen and keep your SA passport; you simply stop being a SA tax resident for SARS purposes.

Edge cases worth knowing

For SA expats who started the old financial emigration process before March 2021 but did not finish (paperwork was lodged but the process closed before completion), the partial application generally lapsed. You now run tax emigration through SARS as the current route.

For SA expats who did the old financial emigration process AND have proof that SARS treated them as non-resident from that date (e.g. SARS correspondence accepting non-resident filings since 2017), the cessation may already be effectively recognised - the formality just needs cleaning up. A practitioner review confirms the position before any new steps.

For SA expats who never did financial emigration and never did tax emigration (the most common starting point in our experience), the current path is tax emigration through SARS. The SARB side is now irrelevant because the SARB resident/non-resident distinction was scrapped in 2021.

For SA expats whose spouses also need to address residency status, each spouse runs through tax emigration independently. The SARS process is per-person, not per-household. Both can run in parallel through WBForex.

For our companion piece on the complete cessation of tax residency process, the operational mechanics including the Section 9H deemed disposal calculation are covered in depth.

A word from Peter: "This is one of the most common confusions we untangle. A client tells us 'I emigrated in 2018' and we have to ask which kind. If the answer is the old SARB process, we then have to explain that the tax side is still open. It is not anyone's fault as such - the terminology was always loose and the rules genuinely changed in 2021. But the practical consequence matters. The three-year clock starts from SARS cessation, not from SARB emigration. Get that wrong and your retirement planning is out by years."

Not sure where you stand?

WBForex can review your current status across both SARB and SARS and advise on what steps you actually need to take. Contact WBForex for a free consultation.

FAQ